CSA mistakenly send me someone else’s bank details
A few weeks ago (January 20th) I asked the CSA to send me a breakdown of what I paid to date, and what I owed. I recorded the phone call, because I knew they’d either lie about my requesting it or just muck it up. Sure enough, when I phoned back some weeks later they had no recollection of my having called (even though I had) so I asked the same question again.
This time a chap named Barney said he’d send me the details, which to his credit, he did. I did tell him I was recording the call though, so he’d have struggled to worm his way out of it.
I received my details through the post in a timely fashion; however, I also received something else. I received something which highlights a level of incompetence and lack of organisation that only the child support agency has the ability to display. They sent me a printout of internal email between one of their accountants, Natalie Walters, and Patricia Corris. In the email, Natalie asked Patricia to update the details on a PWC (parent with care), and printed the woman’s bank account number and sort code for her building society.
This email was printed out by Patricia Corris, left lying around on the printer at the CSA in Birkenhead, and then picked up and posted to my address! In doing so, Patricia Corris broke data protection laws.
Here’s a copy of the email, with the bank details removed (because I’m not incompetent like the CSA):
Corris Patricia CSA Birkenhead
From: Walters Natalie CSA Birkenhead
Sent: 09 February 2009 19:42
To: Corris Patricia CSA Birkenhead
Subject: ******4210Sorry trish am on training now and the phones have been mad im trying 2 do me 2 pieces of post b4 she has me ha.
Will you update iico please for pwc bank details sc 165521 acct num ******62 thanks don’t forgetNatalie
OA3 Accounts
Ext 2463
You’ll notice by the mix of broken English and text speak that Natalie isn’t the sharpest tool in the box, and by the fact that Patricia printed an email containing someone’s bank details and left it lying around on the printer for some other bright spark to pick up and post to random people, it’s clear that the CSA isn’t really filled with geniuses.
So, if you’re a parent with care and your bank is the Cumberland Building Society, Cumberland House, Castle Street, Carlisle, CA3 8RX, with the sort code 16-52-21, your bank account details may have been printed out and posted to me. Perhaps they’ve been posted to other people as well? Who knows!
The real question is, what did the CSA have to say about this? Let’s ask them!
Here’s the recorded phone call of what happened when I phoned the CSA to tell them of their gross negligence.
As you can hear, they ‘claim’ they’ll contact the PWC to let her know about the screw up, and they ‘claim’ that a manager will be involved. I doubt either will happen, so I phoned the Daily Mirror and got a journalist on the case. He spoke to the CSA, and received a grovelling letter back from them admitting the mistake, but I have yet to hear back from them, either in writing or by phone call. I was promised that Patricia Corris would call me to apologise, but she hasn’t.
Hopefully she’s been sacked. Hopefully the whole of the Birkenhead office has been sacked, but sadly I doubt it. This type of cock up is hardly out of the ordinary, and I expect the CSA will continue to do this until the whole organisation is shut down amid mass public outcry. How many screw ups will this take though? How many CSA mistakes must we endure before something is done?
If I wasn’t laughing so hard I’d be crying right now.
I'm an Affiliate Marketeer, SEO, web developer and all round Internet personage. I run a network of content websites on a variety of different subjects. I'm also victim to some of the worst luck in the world, and I tend to Blog about all of it here. 
Loading ...
Posts
o_O
I just can’t believe it…
I’d like to say I can’t believe it but I can!
Their incompetence is truly breathtaking.
I can see a juicy fine on the way from the information commissioner…
http://www.ico.gov.uk/
But then it will be tax payers fining themselves, plus administrative costs.
Well done for standing up and publicising your very real and atrocious experiences with the CSA. It is all too easy for those who have not had to deal with the CSA to assume they are rightfully collecting money from irresponsible parents and fulfilling their image of reducing child poverty.
The reality of their maladministration and abuse of power, purely to meet financial targets, with total disregard for the lives they ruin in the process or the real issue of child welfare, is never highlighted to the public.
Keep up your fight and I hope you manage to make ripples in the right pond so the public get to find out what the CSA are really about.
[...] the full details here, and even listen to the phone call. share this [...]
[...] if you’ve been troubled by the CSA, maybe they’ve sent your bank details to someone else or whatever the story, tell the BBC [...]
[...] I guess. Because my efforts to get them to admit their mistakes proved fruitless, even when they posted someone else’s bank details to me, I set up the anti-CSA website [...]
The CSA sent a court letter with a statement containing all my personal details eg. NI number, date of birth amount owed, daughters name date of birth my address etc to someone else what can I do they are a law unto themselves